# B6 independent PM review v001

Status: **LIVE TWO-PROJECT PROOF CONFIRMED — B6 CLOSURE INCOMPLETE**.
This review supersedes any premature B6 PASS wording in B6_LIVE_STATUS_v001.md, B6_LIVE_EVIDENCE_v001.json and the public status page. It does not change historical execution facts.

## Independently confirmed
- Live release: `1b04cdc1308dc2c80dad06c229f1a43e71aa262a`; Agent Agency service active.
- Live projects: exactly `abamama` and `agent-agency`. Spherum absent/cancelled.
- Mama Aba preserved: 6 tasks, 5 Missions, 4 Runs, 5 Results.
- Agent Agency: 3 tasks, 1 actual Mission, 1 Run, 1 currently marked accepted Result.
- Both project workers present with fresh heartbeat observations.
- Nine live authentication/isolation checks passed, including foreign worker polling, heartbeat and self-enrollment/rebinding denials. Anonymous Projects returns 401.
- Independent clean worktree gate at the exact live release: lint, typecheck, Hub 136 tests, Bridge 30 tests, build and diff-check PASS; production dependency audit reported 0 vulnerabilities.
- Native pilot launch and same-session review are recorded for session `89c548f0-c1d2-465d-a3b5-76bfd083e499`; launch operation terminal/ACKed.
- Independent raw Git blob + remote preview readback: `17be39742ecee3c1e5a5be419f6cd630fa3f014d` on `pilot/b6-agent-agency-self`.
- Exactly one changed file: `target-v2/implementation/b6/B6_SELF_DOGFOOD_HANDOFF_v001.md`; all B5 files unchanged.
- Handoff blob SHA256: `ac0813b741d38fece2c204d65af97b758826d506adb0968d9a9dd43bd91ced0c`.
- Candidate digest: `1da7325060244ca2025781751d0b859d9a02896d940c43dc3f7a840b4d381dda`.
- PM semantic review of the handoff against pinned B5 v002: consistent. The document labels historical facts and does not claim live B6 acceptance.

## Proven closure gaps
1. Live Mission still has status `planned` although the Run is terminal. Task/item completion and artifact links require reconciliation.
2. `persist-b6-result.mts` directly writes accepted state/custom verification JSON instead of executing the B4 candidate/assessment/publication APIs. The live ledger contained only the completed launch boundary, no B4 publish boundary. Preview push occurred, but a fenced B4 publication path is NOT proven.
3. Runtime lifecycle is only partial: Mama Aba still observed on the old pinned b818 runtime; Agent Agency observed running TypeScript from the mutable implementation worktree. Both workers must be converted to a validated versioned, single-instance supervised setup before claiming this gate complete.

## Backup and remaining external gates
Encrypted off-host backup is configured and the copy record reports snapshot `20260919T004817Z` on PLAN. Existing restore evidence from `2026-09-19T00:45:25.571Z` reports both projects, recovery_readonly, effects denied and epoch advanced. Existing tamper evidence reports rejection. A repeat direct PowerShell invocation in this PM pass was denied by the host execution policy; its subsequent printed completion marker is NOT new restore evidence. Policy was not changed. Refresh the restore proof after ledger reconciliation.

Google Drive remains genuinely unconfigured. No approved folder ID/URL or application OAuth consent/configuration has been established. A ChatGPT Drive connector is not a deployed Hub credential. No Drive access, folder creation or active-Mission context mutation is claimed.
B7 destructive retirement is not authorized by the ordinary B6 scope. Legacy files/history were not deleted. Its read-only inventory and explicit cutover/rollback review remain separate from deletion.

## Execution disposition
The v004 operator implementation run was stopped after these gate discrepancies were found; the actual completed native Mission was NOT rerun, and live Hub/project Bridge processes were left in service.
A bounded correction assignment was saved as `B6_PM_GATE_RECONCILIATION_v005.md`. Attempting to launch that corrective executor was rejected by the tool safety check. No alternate privileged launch was attempted. The corrective run is NOT active.
The substantive correction is still needed: preserve the original result/evidence, independently assess the exact candidate via B4, record the already-existing preview publication as readback-only reconciliation (not a new or retroactively fenced push), and complete consistent Mission/Task/Artifact facts.

## Verdict
The product is live and the real two-project execution has occurred. Code tests and live credential isolation passed. **This is not yet B6 release acceptance or completion of all remaining product requirements.**