{
  "verdict": "PASS",
  "scope": "Independent bounded UX/product and targeted native feasibility REVIEW of HTML design artifacts only; not Owner approval/native build/device acceptance",
  "reviewer": "Codex agent /root/mobile522_native_readiness; independent of Astra designer",
  "checked_at": "2026-11-08T21:36:14.431339+00:00",
  "reviewed_sha256": {
    "index.html": "a8ab550f61c318515475b74631e7a6a5763d66bd983285a07ca351c38e03581a",
    "prototype.js": "0d9703d04358dea1ce664ac69a477970bc241b4c43d7bab3112df099a519c288",
    "prototype.css": "c75d3ae5d01c09bde69a29b2f23f7b1e36fcc8a64b323cdad869d89e9913c62d",
    "flows.md": "954cb1d59449e1432df4f674e2bf36f35863c6419dbe21cfcb7a59c532fb6c79",
    "permissions.md": "61686cea4ce4a0b082ff47f3b7ace516663f714a0a2508572f214d5729e62513",
    "implementation-spec.md": "f067688501b565ae14bf5be79f429be08be94237647cc7efd2bef1ffcd4ab46f",
    "native-plan.md": "4a9a57e9c411f542e10aa2eb1b14a523c837fc138ebfd0c1e82964e3ea9ae8d1",
    "research.md": "f79150bdc54fbf4e4ff44aafbae1ac748b0d7930234e76030cecc0e1f70f6882",
    "README.md": "027d68966899854db612ba1faa63ea2e95f09bd675ef7be2ad99bfd1e8e7fc36"
  },
  "findings": [],
  "actual_independent_checks": [
    "Visually viewed first-ios-normal.png and wrong-code-ios-compact.png",
    "Actual Chromium guest→manualcity→game→emailfixture→success: status stays null until explicit refreshed confirm",
    "Actual explicit submit produces fixture pending, never auto-confirmed place",
    "Actual OAuth cancel returns same guest game",
    "Four platform sizes location denied at200%: no overflow/small controls, Radar OFF",
    "Read flows/permissions/native plan against actual auth/provisioning/join source and full Owner request; firstparty email does not silently solve AppStore4.8"
  ],
  "browser_result": "independent-browser-result.json",
  "reuse_evidence": [
    "Operator browser-geometry172 cases and browser-interactions9 checks, not mislabeled independent execution"
  ],
  "harness_repairs": [
    "Exact accessible button locator for after-auth and cancel-auth, because close icon and body CTA intentionally share actions; no product change"
  ],
  "not_tested": [
    "Real OAuth/email transport/native exchange/refresh",
    "Native binary/device installation",
    "Physical iOS/Android permission behavior/APNs/FCM",
    "VoiceOver/TalkBack and actual DynamicType",
    "Store review/accounts/signing",
    "Owner concept/MVP approval"
  ],
  "limitations": [
    "Fixture city/game data intentionally synthetic and externally labeled; no claim of fetching livecatalog",
    "Native-plan baseline metadata is candidate, no installed Expo project",
    "Review validates presentation/contracts, not legal approval or guarantees of AppStore acceptance"
  ],
  "metadata_delta": {
    "accepted": true,
    "scope": "index/README statuses and links, actual model attribution, corrected engineer copy with explanatory prelude; no functional changes",
    "checked_at": "2026-11-08T21:37:54.653382+00:00",
    "prototype_and_contract_hashes_unchanged": true,
    "engineer_body_exact": true
  }
}