{
  "verdict": "PASS",
  "scope": "Independent bounded UX/product + targeted native feasibility of V2 design artifacts; no source/build/store/Owner approval",
  "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-11-09T19:20:45.244542+00:00",
  "independent_from": "actual Astra gpt-6-astra/high designer; reviewer no model/provider calls",
  "owner_V1": "REJECTED_ENTIRELY_PRESERVED",
  "owner_V2_approval": "PENDING",
  "blocking_findings": [],
  "resolved_metadata_findings": [
    {
      "id": "V2-META-01",
      "issue": "README historical author-terminal NOT_RUN conflicted with later actual operator checks",
      "resolution": "README now labels original NOT_RUN as historical and links current external/independent review; runtime unchanged"
    }
  ],
  "independent_browser_checks": [
    "Guest city unknown has honest empty result; manual Kazan preserved without geolocation/auth",
    "Wrong then valid code preserves selected second game/city and requires fresh confirmation; no account enumeration",
    "Only explicit new submit transitions to synthetic pending",
    "Deep link bypasses story; OAuth external simulation and cancel retain recovery context",
    "Radar consent explicit/unchecked; auth resets consent; OS approximate grant does not enable visibility",
    "Separate visibility confirmation is required after OS result",
    "OS denial preserves usable catalog and returning entry bypasses introduction",
    "Independent compact360/375 × conceptsA/B/C at200%: no horizontal overflow, labelled44px controls and guest CTA reachable by scrolling"
  ],
  "independent_browser_engine": "owned Chromium1243 via existing Playwright; sandbox enabled",
  "js_errors": [],
  "external_requests": [],
  "reviewed_sha256": {
    "index.html": "19432ff0f448502deabd562fc708fcb452439f563ad522413c783e5849b9b06a",
    "README.md": "36084c710f4ea48d69bf08ff7118eea646c3313607254cffabb0207575d32630",
    "research.md": "d262180bea07f7448103aee885445fefb57d29214d491c92d4a0e93e42b28d4e",
    "concept-comparison.md": "d5e3cbf16e2da844e3c3c1544cb57aab7623cddb02704398041fc206332c6ef5",
    "prototype-manifest.json": "f298b3f1dca8c0c5d171960501699b1c2bc36d7f389ea9ba0e2c4f149b904390",
    "prototype.html": "30905c3c832c68c935a4e9dcb7aa5f333e74f2eaf212a06fc19c09ea312de45b",
    "prototype.js": "9ebf24862811f118c8505f9e2985ce1d9d015a6aecb61050461d41a49d4f90dd",
    "prototype.css": "23ee07ed068cbf7ca7cf91127d02d55e1975e96f3d13da792533ac321ffed215",
    "gallery.js": "6fe449d001864208cd98694445d270a8cb67c935aad067ea166956c910d65b18",
    "gallery.css": "ea8d8bbcf224f734d0409be15bb7e99371d4b9ce23efc9c56893085e596c7de6"
  },
  "native_feasibility": {
    "selected_architecture": "existing React Native + Expo/Expo Router retained",
    "scoped_source_equivalence": "df1d7652 auth/mobile/IOS_ANDROID/AUTH/social-profile-defaults bytes unchanged through accepted68 tree-equivalent candidate568fe044 (read-only git diff empty)",
    "source_ready": "NOT_IMPLEMENTED",
    "build_ready": "NOT_BUILT",
    "device_tested": "NOT_TESTED",
    "store_ready": "NOT_READY",
    "native_sessions_OAuth_email_links_push": "NOT_IMPLEMENTED_NOT_TESTED",
    "iOS4_8_accounts_signing_privacy": "Owner/external gates retained; email not automatic4.8 exemption"
  },
  "limits": [
    "Browser HTML/CSS prototype and simulated state machine, not native API transport",
    "VoiceOver/TalkBack, realOSdialogs/keyboard, devices/push/auth/build/store not tested",
    "AppleHIG latest full body not observed; research states that limitation, historical supplied guidance labelled",
    "Gameplay/city/user data synthetic and explicitly annotated outside phone",
    "Radar consent wording draft must bind actual server version/eligibility/retention before implementation",
    "Publication externalHTTPS not performed by reviewer; private inputs/logs/launchers must remain excluded"
  ],
  "model_calls_by_reviewer": 0,
  "source_edits": 0,
  "publication_by_reviewer": false
}