{
  "verdict": "PASS",
  "date": "2026-11-09",
  "scope": "Independent bounded local UX/product+targeted source-feasibility review of R2 design artifact, not product source QA/DEV/UAT",
  "reviewed_sha256": {
    "index.html": "e73635fd142e92d3ca5a7fdc0e646aa03fe6a7586c274a26e3911f0dbb1a8b3f",
    "prototype.html": "25df7d35e45286c4530cf036b2d1e4eedcb82e6471b5ab260cc0a9e29d7ca24f",
    "prototype.js": "29728af1a04da15a3d411b9301bc7b28a17ec42234bc868219da163e4c180d0c",
    "styles.css": "501489d8316fe4fdb3542a736d445d5515e7b5355625017e322624a4850a0601",
    "README.md": "b427cf158d0909b23f2909286b0a1519cef38cf9ea9d5926078bb6627e69c884",
    "artifact-manifest.json": "56a8c7d16b1046f0a32c1298b9c58cae91b0a0fc3b6a9fda7845b10bf247ca7d",
    "capture-plan.json": "fdf1b20fa60c2ea8b89cbffc5688b21c79f8f3963977d3e768634741c1a6234e",
    "operator-browser-result.json": "b8bc29a7ee6bd9a4c4b1e4a87c7a5a10d8e61db00cabbdd8d010fd4de756bdfe",
    "operator-enlarged-text-result.json": "261a8db33d3e62ae552b4030da27b5a8ec6ef404241a38d47e6378ca84e5bc95",
    "independent-browser-result.json": "90d298216492daf476453c7b265ed93461cde0bf2fd9ff0aae6c909a2cedffa8",
    "independent-presentation-delta.json": "f575903840918e0b45070335f48b9deae1ac6add4898f26ff61e7550ec3961fa"
  },
  "independent_geometry_cases": 20,
  "independent_contract_groups": [
    "Fixture generation: OFF/actor invalidation reject late settlement; pending stop preserves ON/UNKNOWN; only stop-confirm clears; alreadyON/background/scope do not arm loader",
    "390: one list, explicit physical ON only, no optimistic ON; consent/geo→confirm→firstread removes loader; server-order fixture; OFF invalidates display without optimistic OFF",
    "1280: one list, explicit physical ON only, no optimistic ON; consent/geo→confirm→firstread removes loader; server-order fixture; OFF invalidates display without optimistic OFF"
  ],
  "javascript_errors": [],
  "external_requests": [],
  "blocking_findings": [],
  "resolved_findings": [
    {
      "id": "R2-1",
      "issue": "Physical OFF originally reset confirmedON optimistically",
      "repair": "off_intent invalidates display generation but preserves confirmedON/pendingStop; only stop_confirmed clears, unknown preserves",
      "verified": true
    },
    {
      "id": "R2-2",
      "issue": "Initial loaded fixture demonstrated city order/unknown distances, not nearest primary path",
      "repair": "Main authorized-origin synthetic ordered B,C with explicitly fictional approx2/3km; separate ready_city/no-origin fallback",
      "verified": true
    }
  ],
  "harness_correction": "existing_on deliberately represents alreadyON plus current valid snapshot, so ready without loader is valid. Replaced overly strict idle expectation with not-loading; scope_change subsequently idle. Product was not changed for this harness correction.",
  "source_gaps": [
    "Explicit-intent callback and display-generation binding absent in current source.",
    "Matching first-READ dispatch/settlement correlation must be implemented narrowly in existing query controller.",
    "Existing read transport has no finite deadline; bounded first-read completion/fallback must be chosen and tested in source admission, without abort/replay of unresolved activation write."
  ],
  "boundaries": {
    "SourceImplementation": "NOT_STARTED",
    "SourceQA": "NOT_TESTED",
    "CI": "NOT_TESTED",
    "DEVAcceptance": "NOT_TESTED",
    "OwnerUAT": "NOT_TESTED",
    "additionalOwnerGORequired": false,
    "V1": "HISTORICAL_SUPERSEDED"
  },
  "presentation_delta": {
    "verdict": "PASS",
    "scope": "Only default idle presentation and collapsed external review/lab controls; no new concept/source/state-machine review",
    "checks": [
      "Default gallery idle; gallery tools and external labelled lab collapsed",
      "Physical ON opens only external lab without early loader; admit/confirm/read removes loading normally",
      "Recovery opens labelled external lab then focuses trace; no simulated recovery result"
    ],
    "javascript_errors": []
  },
  "metadata_delta": {
    "verdict": "PASS",
    "changes": "Gallery title only; README documents default idle/collapsed external simulation tools/manual synthetic server responses; artifact manifest refreshed. Runtime unchanged from targeted three actual checks.",
    "sha256": {
      "index.html": "e73635fd142e92d3ca5a7fdc0e646aa03fe6a7586c274a26e3911f0dbb1a8b3f",
      "README.md": "b427cf158d0909b23f2909286b0a1519cef38cf9ea9d5926078bb6627e69c884",
      "artifact-manifest.json": "56a8c7d16b1046f0a32c1298b9c58cae91b0a0fc3b6a9fda7845b10bf247ca7d"
    }
  }
}