{ "schema": "reviews394-organizer-trainer-proposal-v2", "status": "TARGETED_DESIGN_COMPLETE_IMPLEMENTATION_AUTHORIZED", "date": "2026-11-03", "canonical_issue": 394, "parent_issue": 372, "source_sha": "1d8a0c9b0115a499a786384c0f60da7de17c66d0", "source_tree": "5a82f31d9ca1f4a1f3b8bcd27e97bf919628178f", "installed": { "sha": "7f33e9da0cf7b52d260567bbfb37114a3613d479", "app": "alpha19", "api": "0.27", "receipt": "r41479055286-a2", "evidence": "trusted assignment; no runtime inspection" }, "current_vs_proposed": { "private_organization": "installed: score 1..5 and/or text; broad discrepancy policy", "private_training": "installed: text only, no skill score; broader than confirmed experience", "peer": "installed: private strict shared experience", "public_role_experience": "proposed; not installed", "PR471": "installed private received PEER report + assigned independent exact revision read only", "venue": "separate unfinished scope; broad writer closed" }, "precedence": "deny on missing authorization; hold on unresolved basis; eligibility does not publish; approval never bypasses privacy", "public_submission_all_of": [ "active authorized actor/session and existing write restrictions", "durable submission + existing Cases queue/link atomically available; reviewer online or assignment NOT required", "exact own event ended by server time", "published or completed event; held outcome", "eligibleFromTransitions historical participation", "present by manager_explicit or case_reviewer; actor != attendance subject", "no unresolved attendance or held/role basis dispute", "historical role subject proven, not current-role guess", "author != subject across account identity", "for training: trainer_led plus actual historical instructor service, no unresolved substitution", "target role public projection available under existing visibility rules", "public draft separate from private record", "exact projection consent for this revision" ], "matrix": [ { "id": "regular_held_present", "condition": "Own eligible regular game; all public gates; proven organizer", "public_organization": "may_submit", "public_training": "not_applicable", "private_service_feedback": "existing_private_policy_only", "action_ru": "Отзыв об организации" }, { "id": "training_held_present", "condition": "Own eligible trainer_led event; proven organizer and actual trainer; all gates", "public_organization": "may_submit", "public_training": "may_submit", "private_service_feedback": "existing_private_policy_only", "action_ru": "Выберите предмет; не копировать отзыв в обе роли" }, { "id": "outsider", "condition": "No historical participation", "public_organization": "deny", "public_training": "deny", "private_service_feedback": "no_new_right", "action_ru": "Чтение доступных публичных отзывов" }, { "id": "pending_rejected_prestart_withdrawn", "condition": "Explicit non-confirmed transition at event start", "public_organization": "deny", "public_training": "deny", "private_service_feedback": "existing_policy_no_expansion", "action_ru": "Нет подтверждённого участия" }, { "id": "withdrawn_after_start", "condition": "Confirmed as of start; later withdrawn/removed; independent present and all other gates", "public_organization": "may_submit", "public_training": "may_submit_if_training", "private_service_feedback": "existing_private_policy_only", "action_ru": "Поздний отказ сам по себе не стирает посещение" }, { "id": "missing_mark", "condition": "No attendance assertion; version 0", "public_organization": "hold", "public_training": "hold", "private_service_feedback": "existing_private_policy_only", "action_ru": "Посещение ещё не отмечено → запрос отметки" }, { "id": "unknown_mark", "condition": "Existing unknown assertion; version >0", "public_organization": "hold", "public_training": "hold", "private_service_feedback": "existing_private_policy_only", "action_ru": "Уточнить посещение" }, { "id": "absent_no_show", "condition": "Explicit absent", "public_organization": "deny_until_corrected", "public_training": "deny_until_corrected", "private_service_feedback": "existing_private_policy_only", "action_ru": "Уточнение при ошибке; не выдавать запись на игру за посещение" }, { "id": "late_present", "condition": "Permitted present with late=true; other gates valid", "public_organization": "may_submit", "public_training": "may_submit_if_training", "private_service_feedback": "existing_private_policy_only", "action_ru": "Опоздание не публикуется и не лишает допуска" }, { "id": "open_dispute", "condition": "Open dispute even if latest mark changed to present", "public_organization": "hold", "public_training": "hold", "private_service_feedback": "existing_private_policy_only", "action_ru": "Дождаться разрешения по актуальным версиям" }, { "id": "self_mark", "condition": "present asserted by author or self_attested source", "public_organization": "deny", "public_training": "deny", "private_service_feedback": "existing_private_policy_only", "action_ru": "Нужна отметка другого уполномоченного лица либо независимое решение" }, { "id": "nonparticipant_manager", "condition": "Manager with no eligible participation", "public_organization": "deny", "public_training": "deny", "private_service_feedback": "existing_private_policy_only", "action_ru": "Приватный организационный канал по текущим правам" }, { "id": "self_review", "condition": "Author account equals historical role subject", "public_organization": "deny_for_self_role", "public_training": "deny_for_self_role", "private_service_feedback": "existing_private_policy_only", "action_ru": "Нельзя оценить себя; другая роль другого человека проверяется отдельно" }, { "id": "cancelled_not_held", "condition": "Cancelled lifecycle OR explicit not_held", "public_organization": "deny", "public_training": "deny", "private_service_feedback": "existing_private_policy_only", "action_ru": "Приватное обращение об отмене без бейджа посещения" }, { "id": "unknown_outcome", "condition": "No held proof OR unresolved held dispute", "public_organization": "hold", "public_training": "hold", "private_service_feedback": "existing_private_policy_only", "action_ru": "Нужны сведения о проведении; attendance alone недостаточно" }, { "id": "historical_identity_missing", "condition": "Only current manager/trainer known; no trustworthy event-role proof", "public_organization": "hold_affected_role", "public_training": "hold_affected_role", "private_service_feedback": "existing_private_policy_only", "action_ru": "Уточняем, кто проводил встречу" }, { "id": "substitute_trainer", "condition": "Actual instructor differs from binding or disputed", "public_organization": "unaffected_if_organizer_proven", "public_training": "hold_until_independent_role_correction", "private_service_feedback": "existing_private_policy_only", "action_ru": "Не оценивать запланированного тренера за чужое занятие" }, { "id": "role_changed_later", "condition": "Historical proof intact; current organizer/trainer differs", "public_organization": "historical_subject_only", "public_training": "historical_subject_only", "private_service_feedback": "existing_private_policy_only", "action_ru": "Отзывы и ответы не переходят новому исполнителю" }, { "id": "independent_late_correction", "condition": "Cases corrected exact versions, no open disputes; held and role separately proven", "public_organization": "may_submit", "public_training": "may_submit_if_training", "private_service_feedback": "existing_private_policy_only", "action_ru": "Пересчитать допуск без штрафа за ожидание" }, { "id": "queue_persistence_unavailable", "condition": "Cannot persist pending submission and Cases link atomically", "public_organization": "no_false_receipt_reconcile_original_operation", "public_training": "no_false_receipt_reconcile_original_operation", "private_service_feedback": "existing_private_policy_only", "action_ru": "Техническая ошибка или UNKNOWN; не путать с отсутствием человека онлайн" }, { "id": "target_private", "condition": "Target role cannot be publicly projected under existing fences", "public_organization": "closed_surface", "public_training": "closed_surface", "private_service_feedback": "existing_private_policy_only", "action_ru": "Не раскрывать профиль/роль через обходной review endpoint" }, { "id": "replay_after_basis_loss", "condition": "Replay/duplicate create after admission revoked", "public_organization": "deny_or_hold", "public_training": "deny_or_hold", "private_service_feedback": "existing_private_policy_only", "action_ru": "Проверить исходную операцию; не создавать новый intent" }, { "id": "reviewer_offline", "condition": "All own eligibility gates pass, durable queue available, no current assignee or human online", "public_organization": "may_submit_pending", "public_training": "may_submit_pending_if_training", "action_ru": "Отправлено; ожидает назначения человека. Срок неизвестен" }, { "id": "negative_opinion", "condition": "Verified own service experience; evaluative disappointment without policy violation", "public_organization": "may_submit_and_publish_after_human_approval", "public_training": "may_submit_and_publish_after_human_approval", "action_ru": "Критика полезна; адресат не имеет вето" } ], "roles": { "organization": { "subject": "historical responsible host at exact event", "presence_as_player_required": false, "facets_ru": [ "Договорённости", "Ход встречи", "Общение" ], "public_numeric_rating": false, "private_score": "preserve 1..5 optional with comment" }, "training": { "subject": "historical actual instructor of held trainer_led event", "profile_flag_is_sufficient": false, "facets_ru": [ "Объяснения", "Внимание к участникам", "Организация занятия" ], "public_numeric_rating": false, "skill_score": false }, "same_person": "one identity card, explicit role tabs, no cross-role aggregate or automatic duplication" }, "visibility": { "private_service": "author + original recipient under existing policy; no new general staff read", "private_note": "author only, existing manager creation scope unchanged", "peer": "private, unchanged", "game_QA": "existing public-game comment audience and fences; no experience badge", "draft": "own in-memory form; no localStorage persistence; not manager note", "submitted": "author and assigned authorized independent Cases reviewer; no recipient preview", "public": { "author_labels_ru": [ "Участник игры", "Участник тренировки" ], "fields": [ "opaque public review token", "role", "plain text", "0..2 facets", "experience label", "safe role reply", "allowed actions", "permitted roleHandle and subject display", "organization heldGamesCount with confirmed_history scope", "publishedReviewCount", "opaque projectionVersion" ], "forbidden": [ "author accountId/publicPlayerId/name/avatar/profile link", "stable cross-target author alias", "gameId/participationId", "event or publication exact date/time", "private roster/contact/location", "discrepancy/private feedback body", "private cursor payload" ], "subject": "only already permitted public role projection", "anonymity_guarantee": false }, "proof": "private exact versions/provenance; assigned scoped access only" }, "content": { "plain_text_min": 1, "plain_text_max": 500, "optional_facets_max": 2, "links_attachments_mentions": false, "default_audience": "private", "switch_to_public": "new empty independent draft; explicit preview; unchecked consent", "consent_binding": [ "projection revision/hash", "subject", "role", "audience" ], "content_change": "invalidate consent and approval", "public_average": null, "public_counts": "publishedReviewCount = currently visible current approved review slots for this role; replies/pending/removed/withdrawn excluded; separate from organizer heldGamesCount", "negative_neutral": "allowed equally" }, "uniqueness": { "event_fence": [ "author", "event", "historical_subject", "role" ], "public_current_slot": [ "author", "subject", "role" ], "new_event": "update same public slot with independently admitted new basis", "withdrawal": "retains uniqueness and private audit", "same_person_two_roles": "explicit choice, distinct experience content; no auto-copy" }, "publication": { "submission_deadline": null, "mandatory_delay_hours": null, "timing_status": "implementation defaults under latest Owner authorization; no deadline/cooling period or automatic publication", "requires": "exact consent + independent revision approval + valid/reaffirmed basis + current visibility", "states": [ "draft", "submitted", "needs_correction", "held_basis", "published", "revision_waiting", "withdrawn", "removed" ], "transitions": [ { "from": "draft", "event": "explicit public consent + all gates", "to": "submitted" }, { "from": "submitted", "event": "no handler available", "to": "submitted; waiting honest, no auto publication" }, { "from": "submitted", "event": "independent exact approval + fences", "to": "published" }, { "from": "submitted", "event": "adverse correction/open dispute", "to": "held_basis" }, { "from": "published", "event": "author edits", "to": "revision_waiting; old approved revision remains" }, { "from": "revision_waiting", "event": "new exact consent/approval", "to": "published; old reply waits recipient reconfirmation" }, { "from": "published", "event": "unilateral adverse manager change", "to": "published with basis-under-review label + private Case; no automatic removal" }, { "from": "published", "event": "independent invalid basis/policy decision", "to": "removed" }, { "from": "any owned state", "event": "withdraw", "to": "withdrawn; no public reply/text; uniqueness remains" }, { "from": "withdrawn", "event": "explicit resubmit same slot + all gates", "to": "submitted" }, { "from": "published", "event": "report on exact content revision", "to": "published; linked Case; no report-count hide" }, { "from": "removed", "event": "independent restore exact valid consent/revision/basis/visibility; not withdrawn", "to": "published" }, { "from": "submitted", "event": "unassigned or human offline", "to": "submitted with durable receipt; waiting without SLA" } ] }, "reply": { "author": "historical subject in exact role only", "max_current": 1, "text_max": 500, "moderation": "same exact consent/revision review", "threaded": false, "private_identity_disclosure": false, "subject_changed": "no transfer to new manager", "withdrawn_review": "reply hidden", "changed_review": "accepted reply to old revision not silently attached to new text", "withdrawal": "historical subject may withdraw own reply only; never review by another author" }, "moderation": { "reuse": "Cases assignment/step-up/permissions/audit; bounded new public target/action", "not_installed": "public submit moderation, role/outcome basis corrections, public reports/replies and appeals", "COI_excludes": [ "author", "subject", "reporter", "event participant", "historic manager", "creator", "historical trainer" ], "appeal": "same linked history, another independent human reviewer, waiting if none available", "report_count_auto_hide": false, "recipient_veto": false, "private_proof_access": "no public or general staff access", "operational_gate": "durable Cases intake required; reviewer online/assigned NOT a submission gate; no human session means human DEV UAT NOT_TESTED", "first_line": "existing deterministic auth/admission/idempotency/format protections, preliminary flags and report intake; no paid model, truth claims or report-count removal", "human_commands": [ "approve", "retain", "request_correction", "remove", "restore", "resolve_held_or_role_basis" ], "rationale": "required and version-bound; generic Case closure is not publication", "source_access": "assigned current authorized independent principal with step-up; exact review/reply plus minimal proof; preserve existing evidence policy", "pending": "not public; report links exact version if legitimately accessible; no recipient preview before approval", "published_reported": "visible until authorized human remove; privacy fences remain independent", "negative_opinion": "allowed; disagreement and disappointment are not harassment or proof of fabrication", "no_new_accounts": true, "no_new_enrollment_platform": true, "cases": [ { "id": "subject_disagrees", "decision": "may_reply_or_dispute; cannot_delete_review" }, { "id": "many_reports", "decision": "queue_only; not_auto_hide" }, { "id": "preliminary_pii_flag", "decision": "human_inspects; flag_is_not_fact_or_approval" }, { "id": "human_confirms_pii_threat_or_fabrication", "decision": "remove_exact_target_with_rationale; author_can_appeal" }, { "id": "human_rejects_report_on_criticism", "decision": "retain_review" }, { "id": "report_on_reply", "decision": "only_reply_removed_if_violation; review_unchanged" }, { "id": "author_withdraws", "decision": "hide_own_review_and_reply; preserve_slot_history" }, { "id": "subject_withdraws_reply", "decision": "hide_own_reply_only" }, { "id": "restore_withdrawn", "decision": "deny; requires_author_resubmission_consent" }, { "id": "stale_decision_or_lost_assignment_stepup", "decision": "deny_without_publication" }, { "id": "appeal_reviewer_original_decider", "decision": "deny_coi" }, { "id": "human_not_online", "decision": "pending_allowed; no_auto_approval" }, { "id": "dev_no_authorized_existing_session", "decision": "code_HTTP_checks_only; human_moderation_UAT_NOT_TESTED; no_credentials_created" } ] }, "restrictions": { "blocks": "current viewer/direct-contact fences; no global erasure or recipient veto", "account_privacy": "current authorized projections; preserve history without bypass", "session_change": "clear protected UI/drafts; retain original UNKNOWN operation receipt safely", "UNKNOWN": "reconcile original key/body; no fabricated success or new replay" }, "checks": "bounded policy + disposable integration for new gates, exact revisions and projection; independent QA, mandatory CI/security, trusted DEV smoke and Owner UAT separate", "open_decisions": [], "release_dependencies": [ "single source writer with immutable revision", "role proof and scoped corrections implemented", "one shared public projection across game/list/profile", "durable existing Cases pending queue with typed human decisions", "one independent Medium QA of different model and mandatory Product CI/security", "trusted DEV accepted release and smoke; human moderation and Owner UAT tracked separately" ], "not_claimed": [ "implementation", "product tests PASS", "independent QA", "DEV acceptance of proposal", "PROD", "public skill rating", "external attendance verification" ], "authority": { "source": "trusted Owner assignment; #394 comment 6590824797", "implementation_after_revision": true, "new_design_approval_required": false, "this_run": "artifacts only; no implementation or external write" }, "reading": { "requires_own_attendance": false, "requires_own_review": false, "requires_booking": false, "authorization": "existing permitted surface privacy/block/session checks; optional session for already guest-public context", "projection": "one role reputation server projector for game/list/profile, no client counts", "matrix": [ { "id": "guest_permitted_game", "read": "allow_safe_role_projection", "write": "require_session_and_verified_own_past_experience" }, { "id": "signed_in_outsider", "read": "allow_permitted_role", "write": "deny_without_experience" }, { "id": "trainer_future_games_empty", "read": "past_role_reviews_remain_if_role_visible", "count": "do_not_reset" }, { "id": "private_profile", "read": "deny_profile; only independently permitted game-role summary may be read", "write": "no_profile_bypass" }, { "id": "private_game", "read": "existing private game 404 preserved; permitted public role aggregate contains no source events" }, { "id": "withdrawn_or_removed_review", "read": "not_in_public_items_or_count" }, { "id": "published_reported_negative", "read": "still_visible_until_human_decision" }, { "id": "pending_review", "read": "author_and_assigned_authorized_reviewer_only" }, { "id": "role_privacy_closed_or_blocked", "read": "current viewer fence; unavailable not zero" } ] }, "organizer_held_count": { "name": "heldGamesCount", "unit": "distinct game_id", "period": "all available confirmed service history through DB now; not lifetime outside service", "all_of": [ "ends_at <= DB now", "lifecycle published or completed", "explicit current accepted held", "accepted historical organization-role proof for subject", "no unresolved held/role basis dispute" ], "includes": [ "regular", "trainer_led", "private/unlisted only in undivided aggregate" ], "excludes": [ "future", "draft", "cancelled", "not_held", "unknown", "missing historical role proof", "unresolved held/role basis" ], "not_denominators": [ "announcements created", "current managers memberships", "attendance rows", "published reviews", "training skill", "all people who ever managed event" ], "privacy": "single count only; no event IDs/dates/roster/locations/public-private breakdown or time/location filters", "label_ru": "Проведено N игр по подтверждённой истории", "zero_ru": "В подтверждённой истории пока нет проведённых игр", "history_may_be_incomplete": true, "backfill": "exact historical provenance or independent Cases correction only; no current-role inference", "correction": "versioned accepted evidence; recalculate distinct count; review content dispute alone does not change it", "same_person_roles": "organizer count includes organized trainer_led game once; no combined role total", "demo_numbers": "15/20 are illustrative only; never real seed aggregates", "cases": [ { "id": "ended_published_held_proven", "delta": 1 }, { "id": "ended_completed_held_proven", "delta": 1 }, { "id": "private_held_proven", "delta": 1, "public_event_details": false }, { "id": "duplicate_revisions_multiple_reviews", "delta": 0 }, { "id": "future_or_draft_or_cancelled", "delta": 0 }, { "id": "unknown_or_missing_history", "delta": 0 }, { "id": "later_manager_change", "old_subject": "retain_if_proof_valid", "new_subject": "no_automatic_credit" }, { "id": "role_or_held_disputed", "count": "exclude_until_independent_resolution", "review": "separate_published_basis_under_review_state" }, { "id": "review_report_or_one_attendance_dispute", "count": "unchanged" }, { "id": "backend_unavailable", "count": null, "display": "unavailable_not_zero" } ] }, "surfaces": { "existing_training_list": "/games?activity=trainer_led; GamesDiscoveryPage.tsx + discovery/DiscoveryGameCard.tsx", "to_build_selected_trainer_filter": "same /games list; trainer= URL and trainerRoleHandle API filter; no new dashboard", "game": "/games/[gameId]", "profile": "/players/[publicPlayerId]", "own_write": "/my-games/[gameId]/results?section=feedback", "admin": "existing AdminApp Cases section; configured basePath; no new public admin route", "not_review_composer": "/games/[gameId]/review is participation application", "not_public_trainer_page": "/profile/trainer is own editor" }, "role_history": { "planned": "versioned publish binding plus changes", "performed": "explicit held role confirmation tied to earlier provenance; current binding alone insufficient", "old_events": "verified audit or independent scoped correction only", "substitution": "actual role subject, hold if unresolved", "correction": "append-only exact-version Cases decision; never transfer old review to current manager" }, "delivery": { "one_coordinated_PR_DEV_delivery": true, "source_only_stages_are_done": false, "new_owner_design_go": false, "human_moderation_without_session": "NOT_TESTED; deliver operable pending queue, no invented approval", "product_source_modified_by_this_run": false, "PROD": false } }