{
  "verdict": "PASS",
  "date": "2026-11-10",
  "scope": "Independent bounded UX/product/engineering review of actual addressed1 Astra prototype; not application Source QA",
  "reviewed_sha256": {
    "index.html": "bf873585fb67eef005b547e343e891ee4568991ebec729763ff96a30b611d2dc",
    "app.js": "9cf2a4ee2aefa78c8604f8d4c2e5edd0bb3f857e692d22c040672e917bbf08d9",
    "styles.css": "f5b7940d89220e1880df8645f3576b5a8098f7d49883b19f0838c69d68712595",
    "README.md": "7baa9a0bff10bcf485bd09434727c09db2db14e364e60a238e4aa65818ac9d50",
    "design-manifest.json": "ea295153c2e8adbdff26597c7bed8b7c4ff4937b9b3f9806833473649f741651",
    "assets/onest.ttf": "3faa4b905661849b2332e394b42f91b5bf5575e553c516caa81811e868a4d589"
  },
  "independent_browser": {
    "status": "PASS",
    "checks": [
      "390: private limited50/no fakeabsence/association; closed/provider block edit but allow withdrawal",
      "390: distinct pending/public truth; unavailablepublicquote not substituted from Own.text",
      "390: conflict persists close/reopen; error/UNKNOWN read cannot unlock; successfulfixture11 closes/noautosubmit",
      "390: UNKNOWN freezes exactpacket/key, close cannot abandon, deliberate samepacket retry confirmswithdraw",
      "1280: private limited50/no fakeabsence/association; closed/provider block edit but allow withdrawal",
      "1280: distinct pending/public truth; unavailablepublicquote not substituted from Own.text",
      "1280: conflict persists close/reopen; error/UNKNOWN read cannot unlock; successfulfixture11 closes/noautosubmit",
      "1280: UNKNOWN freezes exactpacket/key, close cannot abandon, deliberate samepacket retry confirmswithdraw"
    ],
    "errors": [],
    "external": []
  },
  "operator_browser_sha256": "3ace15677e5f419b90e102b201c660944c74385ea9c1d3b611c1e532864b74c4",
  "operator_browser_status": "CAPTURED",
  "viewed_screenshots": [
    "published-1280.png",
    "revision-waiting-390.png",
    "withdraw-confirm-390.png"
  ],
  "blocking_findings": [],
  "harness_correction": "Initial harness attempted to reopen after conflict; the design intentionally disables both owner commands and exposes card-level fresh read. Corrected test to assert disabled actions and fresh-read lock; preserved initial harness timeout privately. No artifact/threshold change.",
  "implementation_constraints": [
    "Private profile collection only; public venue/map remains anonymous/read-only.",
    "Only actually returned own IDs/versions; latest50 absence does not prove deletion; no phantom GET/:id.",
    "No original game association inferred from venue or Own DTO; example edit association is explicitly external synthetic provenance. Without genuine exact association/admission, read+withdraw only and honest edit unavailable.",
    "Own.text may be pending COALESCE; old public quotation needs actual public DTO exact reviewHandle match, otherwise visibility-only notice.",
    "Withdrawal independent of14-day edit window/eligibility/provider availability, but retains ownership/session/CSRF/version/idempotency checks.",
    "VERSION_CONFLICT requires successful fresh own read; failed/UNKNOWN reads do not unlock; UNKNOWN write retains frozen packet/key; logout/revoke generation fences.",
    "Implementation must reuse existing consent disclosure/hash and exact server contract, not treat visual demo copy or timers as actual authorization/version/moderation behavior."
  ],
  "boundaries": {
    "SourceImplementation": "NOT_TESTED",
    "SourceQA": "NOT_TESTED",
    "CI": "NOT_TESTED",
    "DEVAcceptance": "NOT_TESTED",
    "OwnerUAT": "NOT_TESTED",
    "model_calls_by_reviewer": 0,
    "additionalOwnerApprovalGateInferred": false
  }
}